With the release of Pope Benedict's Apostolic Exhortation " Sacramentum Caritatis" (sacrament of charity) this week, the blog debate has been absolutely full on. I may be new to this, but the vitriol on both sides of the debate is incredible - especially in a church where we should be able to be truly "Catholic" and have reasoned discussion without constantly criticizing each other meaninglessly and questioning the "validity"of whatever rite, ritual or service we are discussing. And of course, I have probably just identified myself as a raving liberal (which I'm not) and half of the people I am about to link to, and/or discuss, will ignore me ( which is too bad really...)
The argument seems to go like this. Since Vatican II, Liturgy has fallen into a woeful state - mainly because of secular liberalism and other such nasties creeping into how priests and liturgists approach the liturgy. Everything has gone wrong - not enough silence ( I agree) , Bad Music (I am still agreeing), Clergy not sticking to the rite down to the letter of the law (Sometimes good, usually bland), Liturgical Dance (Never seen it done well, but heard about a ballerina who blew peoples minds as an after communion reflection), using glass eucharistic vessels (seem to be missing the point with this one...) - and so the list of supposed, and real, atrocities, continues.
The solution offered by many is simple. Back to the Tridentine rite. Only "Classical" music (especially chant). Use Latin more often (if not all the time). Celebrate the Eucharist with the Priests back facing the people. Its out with the "Community" approach to Liturgy and in with an older "God-ward one" (Personally I think we can have both). Punish those who don't think or do like we do, who ignore the rubrics of the rite, especially because obviously we are the holders of the truth...
True and ... Not true. I became a Catholic because of my experience with the New rite. Not the Tridentine. I have heard truly bad "classical " music at a mass which left me angry and shaken, and been lifted by a simple folk trio who performed with love, skill and reverence. I have yet to hear consistently good homilies anywhere. And I can't imagine trying to take a 5 and 7 year old to a Latin Mass...
So the truth continues to be that we can exist with a multitude of practices, but that all of us should be willing to try and improve our celebrations. And Sacramentum Caritatis gives good guidance in that respect.
I love what Amy Welborn wrote about it "There's a sense in which we are being asked to think about these things at a different level, to focus on the central doctrines, and most especially on the Person at the center of it all." So true - and necessary.
My main concern is how the two sides don't seem to able to communicate without really digging the knife in - not that I don't agree with some of what they say (on both sides), just how upset and angry they seem to get with each other, and then do a blanket exclusion of "Them and their kind"
Check out some of these and let me know what you think.
http://amywelborn.typepad.com/openbook/
http://closedcafeteria.blogspot.com/2007/03/fr-rohrs-approximation-of-mass-at-re.html
http://paramedicgoldengirl.blogspot.com/2007/03/from-mail-mahony-conference.html
http://marymagdalen.blogspot.com/2007/03/emphasis-on-personality.html
Sunday, March 18, 2007
Liturgy Wars
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
11:46 AM
|
Saturday, March 17, 2007
Our Friend, Mike Done
Mike Done, legendery local music artist (he once sang with Chris De Burgh!) is running three websites at the moment
Michael Done's Extremely Creatively Named Blog
"Snoggie the Snail & Jesus" - A Slow Moving Story
and
"The Five Dangerous Graces"
Especially check out this last one for Mikes spiritual journey.
Thanks for sharing Mike!
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
7:01 PM
|
Sunday, March 11, 2007
Mass Reflection
Two great thing at Mass today (I finally made it - with three kids!)
Firstly, Father preached probably the best homliyI have ever heard him give . He compared the Old Testament reading about Moses and the burning bush with the gifts of Scripture and the Eucharist. All three of them keep giving without being depleted, and they increase our faith by realizing we are standing on holy ground when we encounter them.
Secondly, the powerpoint was used VERY effectively to lead the faithful in a self-examination after the homily. It used images and phrases from the readings to stimulate our reflection.
Glad I went.
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
10:20 AM
|
Wednesday, March 07, 2007
The buzz
All busy here.
Using a terrifc Lenten resource called "Everyday with Jesus" - but don't think of Selwyn Hughes. It is a lovely, prayerful, well prepared study of the Lenten Sunday Scriptures.
You can look at it here.
Check out Chris' site for his thinking on ritual, rite anglocatholisicm and other thriling stuff!
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
12:16 PM
|
Thursday, February 22, 2007
Fasting, Taking, Loving and Living.
Ash Wednesday had three very different impacts this year:
Sunday, February 18, 2007
The ABC's of me - er, us.
Tagged by Alan, here's a little more about me (and us!)
A - Available or Married? Married.
B - Best Moment? Probably becoming a Catholic, but in another sense releasing my first CD was immensely satisfying.
C - Cake or Pie? Pie. Blueberry. With Ice Cream.
D - Drink of choice? Usually G and T (How Anglican!) Or beer on a hot day. Red Wine anytime. If no alcohol - I am rather fond of a Citron Presse. Coffee 24/7.
E - Essential Item? Music. Definitely. Paul Weller or The Church.
F - Favorite Colour? Blue. Or Red. With Stripes.
G - Gummi Bears or Worms? What? BBQ Chips thanks.
H - Hometown? Melbourne, Victoria. But I've lived in Perth for the last 25 years.
I - Indulgence? Books. And wine.
J - January or February? January for sure. School in back in Feb and that means work.
K - Kids & Names? 2: Eliza Rose Nicolette and Noah Willem.
L - Life is incomplete without? Community. And sold chunks of hanging out time.
M - Marriage Date? March 22nd, 1997.
N - Number of Siblings? One. Phil..
O - Oranges or apples? Apples. But must be COLD and CRISP.
P - Phobias/Fears: Heights. Failure. Success.
Q - Favorite Quotation?
I sat here thinking of a good one to write. I thought Of Nouwen, De Mello, Merton, Griffiths -who I all love, but all that felt right was a song lyric:
"The past is knowledge, the present our mistake
- and the future we always leave too late.
I wish we'd come to our senses
and see there is no truth
in those who promote the confusion
for this ever changing mood"
Paul Weller, My Ever Changing Moods.
R - Reason to Smile? Watching my kids play. Seeing our extended community gathered. Realizing how lucky I truly am. Playing music.
S - Season? Spring. I'd like to try it in Paris actually.
T - Tag three people! Phil, Shelle, Matt J.
U - Unknown fact about me: I am a MASSSIVE Dr Who fan. Love it. Live it.
V - Vegetable you hate? Brussel Sprouts. Just can;t do it -even with Garlic, Cream and Bacon.
W - Worst habit? Stewing about things and then letting off steam by being difficult or exploding. Not very helpful or mature.
Y - Your favorite food? Curry. Not TOO hot but enough spice to really get you going. With Rice and poppadoms.
Z - Zodiac? Cancer,but that's a disease and lets not bring the tone of this down any further...
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
4:10 PM
|
Sunday, February 11, 2007
The Music of My Mind
On a day where I feel slightly better than I have in a while, I did this for a laugh.
If you LINK to us, have a go too.
Oh the bizarre Wisdom!!!
Instructions: Go to your music player of choice and put it on shuffle. Say the following questions aloud, and press play.Use the song title as the answer to the questions. NO CHEATING.
How does the world see you?
Blessed Be Your Name (Newsboys)
See - I knew I was feeling better ...
Will I have a happy life?
Conversation. Joni Mitchell.
Yep. Love a good natter.
What do my friends really think of me?
She will have her way (Neil Finn).
So finally the Cross dressing secret is out ...
What do people secretly think of me?
If I Like it I do it (Jamiroqui)
OK. Enough of the cross dressing theme ... !
How can I be happy?
Hooked up. (Jamiroqui).
Don't quite get this. More conversations? Drugs? Heart By Pass ?
What should I do with my life?
Utterly Simple (Traffic).
Great song. Great Band. Great Advice.
What is some good advice for me?
Idiot Wind. (Bob Dylan)
OK. Bob. Thanks.
How will I be remembered?
Get Yourself together (The Small Faces)
Sounds fair given the last month...
!What is my signature dancing song?
Already Yesterday (The Church)
Cool. Not dancing song. Like me.
What do I think my current theme song is?
You're a big Girl (Bob Dylan)
Bob - You're not quite getting it here. I need some help. Am I a big girl? Probably.
What does everyone else think my current theme song is?
Only talking sense. (Finn Brothers)
Good choice - if I could understand it...
What song will play at my funeral?
Rainy Night House (Joni Mitchell)
Rain. Night. Funeral. Nice dark theme.
What type of men/women do you like?
Coloured Rain (Traffic)
I like you all!!!!
What is my day going to be like?
All Mod Cons (The Jam)
Nice to finish with Paul Weller. A Mod day would be fab.
Bless ya
C
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
6:20 PM
|
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
Saturday, January 27, 2007
The Silent Life Chapter 1 The Monastic Peace
Purity of Heart
Solitude, poverty, obedience, silence ad prayer dispose the soul for (its) destiny in God. Asceticism itself does not produce Divine union. It only disposes the soul for union, The carious practices of monastic asceticism are more or less valuable to the monk in proportion as they help him to accomplish the inner and spiritual work that needs to be done to make his soul poor, and humble and empty, in the mystery of the presence of God. When ascetic practices are misused, they serve only to fill the monk with himself and to harden his heart is resistance to grace. That is why all monastic asceticism centers in the two great virtues of humility and obedience which cannot be practiced as they ought to be practiced, if they do not empty a man of himself.
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
12:32 PM
|
Friday, January 26, 2007
The Silent Life by Thomas Merton - Part 1.
A series of quotes (and possibly reflections) as we pursue this text.
From the Prologue:
The monk is one who leaves behind the fictions and illusions of a merely human spirituality in order to plunge himself into the faith of Christ. Faith is the light which seizes upon the inner depths of his soul na delivers him up to the action of the Spirit, the Spirit of liberty, the Spirit of Love. Faith takes him, as the power of God took the ancient prophets, and "Stands him on his feet (Ezch. 2:2) befor the Lord. The monastic life is a life in the Spirit of Christ, a life in which the Christian gives themselves entirely to the love of God which transforms him in the light of Christ.
Thursday, January 18, 2007
Friday, January 12, 2007
he's here
Peter Waller, artist and sculptor extra-ordinary, is staying with us a few days. Pete was a member of the community last couple of years,while he was studying Fine Arts at Curtin University. Last year he moved to Tasmania (sob sob!) to do honours, and now, post graduate work in scultpture, using the university's excellent wood working studios.
Pete is in WA for his first solo Exhibition at Gallery East. Click on the link and check out his beautiful work, and the lovely 15th Century Zen prints which and being co - exhibited.
Pete is also reading Thomas Mertons "Mystics and Zen Masters"
Anyone had a read? It looks amazing!!!
Thursday, January 11, 2007
The Best Spiritual Advice You've Ever Been Given...
Lets put together a compendium of advice we've been given that REALLY helped us grow.Email me or comment and I'll put it up.
Chris:
I'd like to say it was "Shut up!" but in fact it was from a Benedictine monk and was "You must attend to all the dimensions of your life - physical, emotional, spiritual, sexual, psychological, relational - if any of these are out of balance, then its tough going".
This stopped me worrying about alot of things, taught me to take one thing at a time, and look at myself with honesty.
Posted by
Chris Kan
at
8:17 AM
|
Labels: discussions
Monday, January 08, 2007
Vows from the past
Thining about the year again, here's some of the promises we made as a community 18 months ago. Worth remonding ourselves of these again...
(If you want to read the original post it is here)
Although we have been meeting together for the last 7 years - can you believe it? - last night we celebrated our First anniversary as the Transfiguration Community. To mark this occasion, we made promises, not vows, to support our community life. Here is what we promised:
We will honor:T
he light of our Benedictine Heritage.
May we always value silence, stillness and prayer
The light of Hospitality.
May we always nourish one another.
The light of Relationship.
May we always remember to value one another, married or Single.
The light of compassion.
May we always be generous in our care for one another.
The light of work.
May we always value each others occupations and activities.
The light of our children.
May we always see them as gifts from God.
The light of faithfulness
May we continue to be faithful to our community life.
The light of honesty
May we continue to share with humor and truthfulness.
The light of Openness.
May we always be open to the work of the Spirit within us.
The light of newness
May our minds not be closed to the adventure of faith.
Thursday, January 04, 2007
Can we be killed by the hero's we love? Authentic Spiritual life and finding our own way...
Right folks. January seems a good time for this sort of reflection as we ponder the year ahead as individuals and as a community...
No one is a Christian in isolation. We are all instructed in the way of Christ in someway. For some, it is a personal contact, for others it is growing up in a family of faith where many points of contacts are made. Others may pick up a book which changes their life and want to find more, or an Internet page, or radio broadcast or an mp3 or in fact anything where we dialogue with someones experience in some way and allow it to speak. whatever the medium, somehow we here the message of Gods love from another and it changes us. And we keep on this road until we take our final breath...
This is all wonderful and appropriate and absolutely necessary (as we all know). And a Christian community like ours, where questions are the bread and butter of our life together, are essential. But there is a danger, and it worries me from time to time when i come across certain web pages, or articles, or books. It is the matter of Adoration. Let me explain. It is way to easy too read about the "Giants " of the faith (whatever that means to us - whether it be Augustine, Frances de Sales, Merton or John Paul 2, our minister or priest, or even another Christian...) and think to ourselves "They did x, y and z and that led them to holiness. by copying them i will too...".
Now imitation is the most sincere more of flattery, and of great use as we start our journey, but at some point we have to say "I am me. This is my way. God is with me. So be it" and use the skills and lessons we have learnt from others. Now, please don't get me wrong, I am not against the church setting up guidelines which point out what is helpful - eg the Eucharist, Reading the Bible, the Liturgical year - but all of these things need to take place within the context of our own slow and steady "working out our salvation in fear the trembling". None of this is an excuse to not do our homework theologically speaking. All of our thinking needss to be a balance of head and heart, with a good pinch of risk taking!
I suppose I am thinking about this year ahead as a community. We need not be anything other than we are, and part of that is a discovery! We have a wonderful set of ecumenical menotrs to guide and love us. We need to see what is us, and what isn't, who we are, and above all, pray and trust, and move forward.
Lets Dialogue.
Wednesday, January 03, 2007
latest sites
Heres a few interesting Sites checked out lately
Louis Louis Exploring contemplative awareness in daily life, drawing from and with much discussion of the writings of Thomas Merton, aka "Father Louie".
CathNews Catholic Headlines from around the world. A wonderful Australian site.
JC Girls This is a little bizzare, but worth a look. Three women from California created JC's Girls as an outreach to the adult entertainment industry. Being mistaken for porn stars is actually part of their strategy...
Hope ya all well
Tuesday, January 02, 2007
Friday, December 29, 2006
Ritual and Rite
To Dance with God
Gertrud Mueller Nelson
Have being flipping through this book, and using its incredible wisdom, for years.
Has any one else out there heard of it, used it, or read it?